Shelter Island, New York beach homes
Shelter Island is a Atlantic-coast town in New York, about 2.1 miles from the shoreline at its center. Browse homes for sale, long-term leases and vacation rentals here, and check today's tides and weather before you go.
- Homes listed
- 0
- ZIP code
- 11964
Get alerts for Shelter Island
We'll email you when a matching home is listed.
Beach conditions in Shelter Island
Updated hourly · NOAA & National Weather Service
Forecast
- This Afternoon 66°F · Areas Of Drizzle
- Tonight 56°F · Areas Of Drizzle then Mostly Cloudy
- Tuesday 70°F · Sunny
- Tuesday Night 58°F · Partly Cloudy
Homes in Shelter Island
No Shelter Island homes are listed yet.
Set an alert above and we'll email you when one is — or list your own.
Beach towns near Shelter Island
- Shelter Island Heights, NY 0 homes 1.7 mi
- Greenport, NY 0 homes 3.2 mi
- East Marion, NY 0 homes 4.3 mi
- Southold, NY 0 homes 4.8 mi
- Sag Harbor, NY 0 homes 5.9 mi
- Orient, NY 0 homes 6.1 mi
- Peconic, NY 0 homes 7.0 mi
- Cutchogue, NY 0 homes 8.3 mi
- New Suffolk, NY 0 homes 8.8 mi
- Bridgehampton, NY 0 homes 9.1 mi
- East Hampton, NY 0 homes 9.6 mi
- Sagaponack, NY 0 homes 9.8 mi
List your Shelter Island beach home
Agents and owners list homes for sale, for lease and as seasonal rentals — and hear straight from buyers and renters.